Muslims in Canada witnessed the horrific attack that left four individuals – three generations – of a single Muslim family dead in the city of London, Ontario. The fallout from that tragedy ricocheted around the world and was a wakeup call to elected officials and decent law abiding citizens to become vigilante against a growing tide of hate-mongers. The hateful targeting of Muslims has now hit an all time high and causing heightened fear and panic among Muslim communities in North America, Europe, Australia and New Zealand. Many Muslims are asking what could they have done to deserve being treated as undesirables in the countries they regard as safe havens and have come to call home. Scores of Muslim youth have found solace in the welcoming embrace of social justice advocates while many have reduced,if not eliminated altogether, their public engagements in civil society. With hate staring us down, what are Muslims to do? How should they respond? Is an inclusive and truly plural society still possible or is that dream fading into oblivion? And more importantly, how should Muslims strike a balance between their private lives of worship and obedience to Allah and His Messenger and their engagements in civil society?